Carrie Tollefson on Life After the Olympics, Calling the Chicago Marathon, and Finding Joy in Running

Episode: S6E32 | Guest: Carrie Tollefson, Olympian and marathon broadcaster | Aired October 15, 2026 | 48 min

Author: Nick Klastava

Podcast Hosts: Nick Klastava & Amanda Katz

Listen: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube

Carrie Tollefson is an Olympian, a five time NCAA champion, a mom of three, and one of the most familiar voices in marathon broadcasting, and she joined Coach Amanda and me just days after working the 2026 Chicago Marathon finish line. I have been a fan since my own college track days, when I was a wannabe 1500 runner getting humbled by my coach and Carrie was running the same event at a level I could only dream about. This episode was not a training breakdown. It was something better. We took apart what it actually feels like to go from competitor to commentator, why she ran three marathons purely so she could talk about them honestly, how she thinks about identity and ambition when the racing stops, and why she wants every runner to stop measuring success with a stopwatch. Also, she used to do the worm down the backstretch at the Big East. We will get there.

Key Takeaways

• Carrie Tollefson ran three marathons for one reason: so she could understand what athletes feel at mile 20 when she is calling a race from the booth.

• The best race coverage tells human stories, not just splits. Stats can be Googled. The person behind the result cannot.

• Elites and everyday runners face the same moments. You cannot relate to 4:45 mile pace, but you can relate to fighting through mile 21.

• Broadcasters and athletes are people too. The running internet is quick to dogpile and slow to say what went right.

• Running identity does not disappear when you stop racing. It changes shape, and it is okay to not have a goal race on the calendar.

• Short, consistent runs count. Carrie runs five or six days a week, and a lot of those are 20 minute runs done with purpose.

• The running community is welcoming and powerful, and it still has work to do on representation, inclusion, and paying professionals what the sport is worth.

• Success is finding your joy. For Carrie Tollefson it is lacing up her shoes. For you it might be something else, and that counts too.

• 
  

Who Is Carrie Tollefson?

If you have watched a major marathon broadcast in the last decade, you have heard Carrie. She represented the United States in the 1500 meters at the 2004 Athens Olympics after winning the Olympic Trials. Before that, she was a five time NCAA champion at Villanova and the first athlete in NCAA history to win both the 3K and 5K titles. Today she works as a broadcaster and analyst for some of the biggest road races in the world, hosts her own weekly show, C Tolle Run, and is a regular voice on the RunDot podcast.

When Amanda asked her who she is beyond all of that, the résumé came last. She is a wife and a mom of three first. She is the youngest of three sisters and says she has the best mom and dad out there. She is a dog mom to Ike. She is a fitness director, a speaker, an MC, and somebody who likes to get after life and, in her words, dance her way through it. That order tells you a lot about how she thinks about the sport.

One small but important detail came up right away. I introduced her as a former Olympian, and Amanda called me out immediately. Carrie was gracious about it and explained that athletes are taught early on: never former, always an Olympian. People in media say former all the time and she does not take offense, but it is worth knowing. I am leaving my mistake in the episode because a man can learn. Amanda also handed out the flowers, the only kind she can keep alive, which is to say dried ones.

From the Worm at the Big East to the Microphone

Carrie and I overlapped a bit in college. I ran at Monmouth, a small Division I school in New Jersey, and Villanova was everywhere back then. I asked if she remembered the meets. She immediately asked if I was a fan of her doing the worm down the backstretch at the Big East championships. It turns out that is what a lot of people remember her for, not the stats. If Villanova won, the sprinters would dare her, and she would do it. The Georgetown people will remember, because it was always Villanova and Georgetown fighting for the title. Amanda has requested video evidence. Somebody check the message boards.

Her broadcasting career started much earlier than most people realize. After finishing second at the USATF Cross Country Championships in her first year as a pro, between Regina Jacobs and Suzy Favor Hamilton, she was interviewed on camera and loved it. She told Toni Reavis, the walking encyclopedia of distance running commentary, that she wanted a role like his someday. He remembered. Within a few months she was helping with Rock 'n' Roll marathon coverage when her schedule allowed, though Toni was the first to tell her that her racing came first and the mic could wait.

So she dabbled for years while she competed, and now it is her main career. Her line for it was perfect: she runs her mouth way more than her legs now. If she cannot be racing, she wants to be talking about racing.

Why Carrie Tollefson Ran Three Marathons She Never Needed to Race

This was my favorite detail of the whole episode. Carrie Tollefson was a 1500 and 5K athlete. The track was home. But after years of calling marathons, she felt like she was missing something. How do you talk credibly about what an athlete is going through at mile 20 if you have never been there? So she ran three marathons, not for a time, not for a bucket list, but to understand what she was describing on air. She said she went through all kinds of gyrations during those races, and it made her a better analyst.

I loved this because it is the reverse of how most people find the marathon. Most of us run one because we want to prove something to ourselves. She ran them to do her job better. And I get the gap she was trying to close. I came up as a track runner too, and the marathon made zero sense to me until I actually ran one. Then I realized it is a completely different sport. You just keep running. And it is terrible. And it is hard.

Carrie pointed out that it goes both ways. Most marathoners have no idea what a 1500 feels like either. Unless you are someone like Kara Goucher or Ryan Hall with a huge range, the events are worlds apart. The lesson for every runner is simple: if you want to understand something, go feel it.

Calling the 2026 Chicago Marathon From the Finish Line

Carrie has worked Chicago in pretty much every role. She has been on the bike, calling what she sees right in front of her. She has been in the booth. She has been at the finish line. This year Paul Swangard and Kara Goucher were in the booth at the NBC studios, and Carrie was at the finish with Ed Eyestone, the BYU coach who has worked with Clayton Young and Conner Mantz. In past years they would have been on motorcycles. This year they were posted at the finish, which turned out to be the best seat for the moment I will get to in a minute.

I asked her what I always wonder when I watch coverage. How do you fill two hours when, for long stretches, nothing much happens? Sometimes the pack is just rolling along for 20 miles, everyone waiting for someone to make a move. They are running ridiculously fast, but not that fast for them. And you still have to talk the whole time.

Her answer surprised me. She loves those stretches. Calling a tight race by splits is like calling a car race, she said, just tracking who is in purple and who is in the lead. That is fun, but the quiet stretches are where you get to tell people who these athletes actually are.

The Stories Matter More Than the Splits

Carrie says she probably should have been a counselor. She loves people's stories, the highs and the lows, and running is a place where people open up. That is what she tries to bring to the broadcast.

Her example from Chicago was Hawi Feysa, who came in as the defending champion and won again, this time in a personal best of 2:13:33, holding off Sharon Lokedi and Brigid Kosgei. Carrie talked to her before the race. After winning in 2025, Feysa went home and built a compound for her entire family. That race changed her life. Carrie also learned that Feysa dealt with food poisoning before Tokyo and still competed. Those are the stories she wants to tell. Stats are a search away. The person is not.

Amanda connected this right back to everyday runners. We live in a sport that is completely tied to metrics. Paces, splits, heart rate, training load. Hearing the human story behind the result makes the whole thing relatable to someone running their first 10K. I think that is the part a lot of coverage misses.

Clayton Young, Vincent Mauri, and the Best Hug of Race Day

Carrie told one story from the finish line that I have not stopped thinking about. Clayton Young, an Olympian who has finished in the top ten at majors several times, ran 2:05:23 in Chicago. That is a big personal best and makes him the second fastest American marathoner ever, about 40 seconds off Conner Mantz's American record. Carrie noted he did it while managing a hamstring issue.

About a minute behind him came Vincent Mauri, who ran 2:06:45 while cramping. Vinnie called this his real debut, because it was the first marathon where he was actually racing other people. He won his first one by something like 15 minutes, completely alone. Plenty of people online pointed out that his Chicago time was not faster than his solo race, and decided that meant his famous treadmill training (yes, at a Planet Fitness) was not working. That is not how any of this works. Racing the fastest people in the world is different than time trialing alone. There are tactics, surges, and decisions you never face when you are 20 minutes clear.

When Vinnie crossed the line, Clayton was waiting. Carrie said it was the biggest hug you have ever seen, Vinnie looking up at the sky, and Clayton, who was one of his idols, giving him all kinds of advice right there. That is the sport. That is why she wants everyone to see the good in it.

Broadcasters, Message Boards, and the Dogpile Problem

Amanda made a point that I think is important. Broadcasters set the tone for how fans talk about athletes. When an athlete gets hurt, has a bad day, or drops out, the internet rarely looks at the human behind it. It goes straight to judgment. It dogpiles. And the people on the mic have the power to shape that conversation. Amanda told Carrie she is the blueprint for doing it the right way.

Carrie took that kindly and then got honest. There is never a broadcast where the crew does not come home to hear how terrible they were. She says she reads LetsRun every single time (she counts the people who run it as good friends) because she genuinely learns what fans want. But you need thick skin. People will say she has no clue what she is talking about, that she put no work in, when she has spent weeks building her notes. She wishes there was just one thread that said: I did not know Hawi Feysa built a home for her family. I did not know Clayton raced through a hamstring issue. This is her livelihood too.

I think it is a human thing. We rarely tell our friends what they mean to us, but we are quick to tell them when they let us down. When the sport got bigger, the tone online changed. In the early 2000s it felt like everyone was just in awe of what people were doing. My approach now is to accept that some people will dislike whatever I do, and focus on the people it helps. Carrie's response was perfect: that is not us runners. That is not who we are.

Elites and Everyday Runners Face the Same Mile 21

This is the part of the conversation I want every runner we coach to hear. Professional runners have better genetics and they train a lot more. That is the gap. But the fear, the doubt, the moment at mile 21 when everything starts to go sideways? We all deal with that. Pros have just built up more mental tools for getting through it.

You cannot relate to 4:45 pace for 26.2 miles. I cannot either. But you can absolutely relate to a runner cramping late in a race and deciding to keep going anyway. That is the same experience you will have in your next marathon. And running is one of the only sports where you get to compete in the same race, on the same day, on the same course as the best in the world. No other sport really gives you that.

Carrie added that the access is wilder than ever. Charles Hicks, who ran 2:05:35 in Chicago right behind Clayton, has a club where people can follow along with his style of training. Strava lets you see what everyone is doing. Sometimes you realize you did the same workout as a pro that week, and that is pretty cool. As coaches we would gently add: do it your own way and at your own volume. But the connection is real, and it is one of the best things about this sport.

Life After Competition: Running Identity When the Racing Stops

Amanda asked the big question. Carrie went from NCAA titles to an Olympic team, with her identity tied to performance metrics. How did she navigate the shift to building a career beyond competing, and what did it teach her about identity and success?

Her honest answer was that she is still learning, and it scares her sometimes. She loves what she does and feels blessed to do it in a sport she has loved her whole life. But her kids are getting older, and she does not want to keep missing things. For her, the transition was natural because she still gets to perform, just in a different way. If she was not going to be on the track, she was going to be on a stage. She has always wanted to be an actress or a weather woman, and broadcasting scratches that itch.

Still, she identifies as a runner and a competitor, and she thinks she always will. The thought of not being in this space scares her. I relate to that a lot. I came into running competitively from day one. High school track, go race all those people. That mindset never really left. What changed for me was becoming a coach. I got to take what I dealt with, my own identity stuff and anxiety around performance, and use it to help other runners. I am still competitive. I am just not as fast as I used to be, so it is easier to say whatever.

I also shared something listeners know if they have been around. Last year I quit my job to focus on Running Explained, partly because I love this sport and partly because I wanted to be a dad who is around for these years with my kids. Carrie's comments about family hit home. Sometimes the question really is which lane you want to be in.

Ambition in a Busy Season: Twenty Minute Runs and No Guilt

Carrie still runs five or six days a week. Some days are 10 miles. Some are seven. But a lot of days are short, hard three mile runs or about 20 minutes, and she has made peace with that. Her fitness goals are on the back burner. She is not training for marathons or fast 5Ks. She is training for life.

She said people at events assume she loves to race, and right now she just does not want to. And she thinks that is okay. Her question was the one I want everyone to sit with: why are we so hard on ourselves? Why do we always think we need a goal race on the calendar? Right now her goal is to be a great broadcaster and a great mom and wife. She admitted even that last one slips sometimes. She joked that she is not sure she and her husband Charlie have been on a date in six months. But that is a season, and seasons change.

Where she is working hardest is letting go of the guilt of feeling like she is not doing awesome at any one thing. Amanda, in full coach mode, pushed back hard. Carrie is not just getting by. She is a whole person who finds fulfillment outside of running, which is a healthy relationship with the sport and with her body. Building a career, raising a family, and staying fit at the same time? Amanda's verdict is those are PRs.

I agree completely. For those of us who came into this sport chasing times, it is okay to have different kinds of PRs later in life. I have not raced in a while. Coaching, sharing what I have learned, and helping athletes skip the six years of workout anxiety I put myself through matters just as much to me now. Carrie's own advice for staying on track was simple: surround yourself with like-minded, goal driven people who pick you up when you need it and kick you in the pants when you need that too.

She also gave coaches a reminder I needed to hear. Sitting at finish lines, she sees two hour marathoners and six hour marathoners, and the joy on everyone's face. Coaches play a huge role in that. It is easy to get lost in writing plans and forget what it means to someone to finish a run walk or a first marathon. I am taking that one with me.

What the Running Community Gets Right, and Where It Can Grow

Amanda asked Carrie what the running community is doing well and where it is making things too complicated. Her first answer was that we are welcoming. That is what she is proudest of. When you ask for change in this sport, people usually try to do better.

She was also clear that there is work to do. We need to be more inclusive and more diverse, and we need more equal representation of men and women on the mic. When she competed, there were very few female voices calling races, and helping change that is part of why she keeps saying yes to work. She mentioned a long run she did with Meb Keflezighi in Chicago, where they talked about the need for more representation in the sport, even in 2026.

Prize Money, Celebrity Run Clubs, and the Running Boom

Carrie's other answer came from the elite side. Josh Kerr broke the world record in the mile this summer in London, and according to Carrie, the bonus he earned was the same kind of money athletes earned for mile world records back in the Hicham El Guerrouj era of the 1990s. Amanda's response: robbery. Chicken prices go up. His bonus does not. Carrie's point is that if we want strong teams at the Olympics and World Championships, athletes need incentives that match the work.

This is why so many pros now have YouTube channels, sponsors, and side businesses, and why Josh built a whole event around his record attempt. Smart athletes have figured out how to make the sport pay. Compared to other professional sports, though, runners are still making pennies.

On the positive side, I love how much the sport has grown. When I started running around 2000, people asked why on earth I was doing it. Now if you tell someone you run, they have run a 5K, a marathon, or know someone who has. Social media and the pandemic both pushed that along. Carrie pointed to celebrity events like Diplo's 5Ks that pull in thousands of runners with a party afterward, and Travis Barker's run club. Amanda added an important caveat: celebrity attention is good for the sport, but it does not replace basic human decency, and not every famous name has a great track record. Carrie's summary works for both points: get more people moving, and be kind human beings.

What Success Means to Carrie Tollefson

My last question before the secret questions was the one I most wanted her answer to. She has spent her career around people chasing big goals. What does she want every runner to know about success that has nothing to do with a finishing time or a title?

For Carrie Tollefson, lacing up her shoes means she is healthy, driven, focused, powerful, and strong. When she puts her head on the pillow at night, she cannot wait to get out the door the next morning. It might be 20 minutes. It might be five days a week or two. Even on the day we recorded, a rest day, she was excited knowing she would meet a group of friends at 5:45 the next morning. Everyone would be tired, and everyone would feel better for it.

Her message: success comes from finding your joy. For her it is the run. For you it might be a walk, a day off, or something that has nothing to do with running at all. We all go through hard things. Find the thing that fills your soul, and protect it.

The Secret Questions

Best advice she has ever received: stop thinking and run. Get out of your head and let your instincts take over. I think about how many PRs happen on days where nothing seems to be going on, because you were not overthinking it. Channel those vibes.

What people are surprised to learn about her: she has never had a drink of alcohol. Not in high school, not in college, not ever. But growing up in a rural Minnesota town of about 1,600 people, she still needed to have some fun. So every now and then on runs, or on a Friday night when the guys drove by in their van, the girls would give them a full moon. Sorry, Ginge. (Ginge is her mom, Virginia, who apparently still tells Carrie to watch her mouth. Amanda is forwarding her this episode immediately.) Amanda confirmed this is not a story she hears very often on the Upper West Side, and that it will remain a no for her.

What she wishes people understood about the running industry: there is good in it. Plain and simple. How we perform comes from how we think, how we move, and how we believe in ourselves. If you bring that positivity to your own mind and body, give it to everyone else too. That is what makes someone everyone's favorite teammate and everyone's favorite coach. We all want to protect our 20 minute run or our two hour long run. Keep the negativity out of that space.

Guest Bio

Carrie Tollefson is a 2004 Olympian in the 1500 meters, a five time NCAA champion at Villanova, and the first athlete in NCAA history to win both the 3K and 5K titles. Raised in Dawson, Minnesota, she is now one of the leading voices in distance running broadcasting, working as an analyst on major marathon coverage including Chicago, Boston, and New York, and she was part of the broadcast team for the 2024 Paris Olympics. She hosts the weekly C Tolle Run podcast, appears weekly on the RunDot podcast, and works as a speaker, MC, and fitness director. She lives in Minnesota with her husband and three kids. Find her at ctollerun.com and as carrie_tollefson on social media.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Carrie Tollefson?

Carrie Tollefson is an American Olympian who ran the 1500 meters at the 2004 Athens Olympics, a five time NCAA champion at Villanova, and a longtime marathon broadcaster and analyst. She also hosts the C Tolle Run podcast.

Why did Carrie Tollefson run marathons if she was a track runner?

She ran three marathons specifically to understand what athletes experience late in the race, especially around mile 20, so she could commentate on marathons with real firsthand knowledge.

Who won the 2026 Chicago Marathon?

Amos Kipruto won the men's race in 2:01:09 and Hawi Feysa won the women's race for the second straight year in a personal best 2:13:33. Clayton Young was the top American man in 2:05:23, the second fastest marathon ever by an American.

How do you keep your running identity when you stop racing?

Let it change shape instead of disappearing. Carrie still runs five or six days a week, often for just 20 minutes, without a goal race on the calendar. Fulfillment can come from coaching, broadcasting, family, or simply enjoying the run.

Is it okay to run without a race on the calendar?

Yes. Seasons of life change, and training for life rather than a specific race is a healthy relationship with running. Consistent, enjoyable running still builds fitness and keeps the habit alive.

What does success in running mean if not a finishing time? As Carrie put it, success comes from finding your joy. For many runners that is simply being healthy enough to lace up their shoes and get out the door.